Wildlife

Recovery: Evicting Rabbits

February 26, 2018

Finn the Wonder Dog on Macquarie Island with king penguins. Photo © Karen Andrew/New Zealand Department of Conservation

Early in the 20th century settlers on the islands of Chañaral and Choros off northern Chile had a brainstorm: They’d create a ready supply of fresh meat by unleashing European rabbits.

It worked out as well as rabbit introduction in Australia.

In short order the aliens stripped away a rich array of native plants (many imperiled), reducing the islands to eroding dirt and rubble. They took over the nesting burrows of Humboldt penguins and Peruvian diving-petrels, now listed by the International Union for Conservation of Nature as vulnerable and endangered respectively. And they knocked down populations of the Atacama tree iguana, many-spotted tree iguana, braided tree iguana, Chilean slender snake, a spider found only on Chañaral and countless insect species including a beetle found only on Choros.

About half a century later settlers had another brainstorm: To cure Chañaral’s biblical plague of rabbits they’d introduce foxes. But the rabbits found sanctuary underground; and the foxes dined on petrels instead, wiping out a nesting population that had once numbered around 200,000. This deprived native burrowing owls of their most important natural diet. It also eliminated the foxes.

Finally, in 2013, people who knew what they were doing worked out a real solution. Island Conservation, a nonprofit team of biologists dedicated to preventing extinctions around the globe, partnered with the Chilean National Forestry Corporation. And, with support from Wisconsin-based pesticide manufacturer Bell Laboratories, Inc. and other U.S.-based funders, they eradicated rabbits on Choros in one year. Chañaral, bigger and with more complex terrain, was certified rabbit free late in 2017.

As on so many other islands success was made possible by the anticoagulant poison brodifacoum, sufficiently fast acting to kill rodents and rabbits before they learn to avoid it. The bait formulation, developed and produced by Bell Labs largely at its own expense, was the same one used in the recent salvation of Desecheo National Wildlife Refuge off Puerto Rico. This time, though, crews were able to deliver bait by hand instead of helicopter because rabbits move around more than rodents.

Choros Field Work. Photo © Island Conservation

All it takes is one part brodifacoum per 40,000 parts bait. But fear and loathing of all poisons in all situations is a global phobia. Always the objections are these, and I’m quoting directly from hard copy and online commentary: “Poison is cruel.” “There has to be a better way.” “The nonnatives didn’t ask to be put there.” “Nontarget wildlife will die.” “Who are humans to call other species invasive?” “Don’t play God by killing one species in favor another.”

“Cruelty” by poisoning aliens doesn’t approach cruelty to natives by not poisoning aliens. There is no “better way,” in fact, no other way. “God” was played by people who made the mistakes of alien introductions, not by people correcting those mistakes. No recovery project ever “killed a species,” only individuals of abundant species in order to prevent extinction of entire species.

Constant practice has rendered Island Conservation adept at outreach. One advantage it had on Choros and Chañaral was that in 1990 Chile had designated these islands — along with a third, Damas — as the Humboldt Penguin National Reserve. Settlers left, and the islands became important for ecotourism, mostly for the rich marine life surrounding them. Today the 2,123-acre reserve sustains 80 percent of the planet’s remaining Humboldt penguins.

Humboldt Penguin (Spheniscus humboldti) on Isla Chañaral, Chile. Photo © Maria Jose Vilches/Island Conservation

“What really changed public attitudes,” explains Island Conservation’s Director of Conservation, Dr. Erin Hagen, “was our before and after photos along with [partner-sponsored] tours of Choros after eradication. There was amazing plant recovery. Barren fields and rocks now teem with herbaceous plants. Diving petrels are expanding; we’re seeing more and more burrows and more occupied nests. The increase in penguins is slower but steady. Some of the more vocal opponents actually wound up helping us monitor rabbit removal.”

Choros before and after rabbit removal. Photo courtesy of Island Conservation

“In the course of a year the seed bed that was there took off, and the island just lit up like a Christmas tree,” adds Island Conservation’s Project Leader, Maddy Pott.

By 2016, when rabbit eradication got under way on Chañaral, opposition consisted entirely of a single Facebook condemnation of brodifacoum. The poster was immediately shouted down by project supporters.

Now life on the islands themselves, as well as in the surrounding sea, is drawing tourists.

Choros before and after rabbit removal. Photo courtesy of Island Conservation

“What we hear again and again is how fast and how amazing recovery is,” declares Bell Labs’ Craig Riekena. “Our company has been involved in about 75 island projects around the world, often with The Nature Conservancy. “I wish sonograms had been taken before and after some of these projects so people could first hear the dead silence [of alien-infested islands] and then the plethora of bird song and other wildlife sounds after recovery. It would really strike home.”

Karen Andrew of the New Zealand Department of Conservation doesn’t wear her emotions on her sleeve, inured as she is to the grim realities of nature. Before her time in Chile she’d worked on rabbit eradication on Australia’s 32,124-acre Macquarie Island in the Southern Ocean, an enormous undertaking that, along with cat, rat and mouse eradication, has recovered or stabilized eight sea-bird species rangewide and significantly benefitted six others. Andrew left Macquarie early in 2014 when it was a mess of bare dirt and landslides. When she returned in January 2018 and saw the “phenomenal growth of lush, new vegetation” she wept.

Finn with his rubber booties. Photo © Karen Andrew/New Zealand Department of Conservation

Certifying islands rabbit free is demanding work, and it would have been virtually impossible without Finn, a dedicated and enthusiastic Island Conservation researcher who had been incarcerated and placed on death row. Finn is a yellow Labrador retriever rescued at the 11th hour from a New Zealand pound and trained to sniff out rabbits.  Finn’s reward for finding them is pats and play time, which includes fetching a tennis ball wrapped in rabbit skin.

“He’s got big eyes filled with devotion and a tail that doesn’t seem to stop wagging,” reports Andrew who deployed him on Macquarie and Choros. “Because of the rough terrain on Choros and Chañaral he had to wear rubber booties. I gave him some training before we went to Chile so he could get used to them. He was very distracted by them at first; it was quite comical.”

One thing island-recovery critics have right is that nontarget bykill is nearly inevitable. On Choros and Chañaral a few turkey vultures, black vultures and passerines succumbed. But what the critics don’t comprehend is that, in ecological and species-level contexts, this bykill has zero significance.

For each new project the partners prepare in-depth, EIS-style risk assessments with accurate bykill projections. And, while any bykill is regrettable, over the years it has steadily diminished.

Diving-petrel burrows on Choros Island, Chile. Photo © Tommy Hall/Island Conservation

Bell Labs limits bykill by making short-lived baits. “The ideal pellet will last a week or two, then break down,” says Riekena. “When Gregg Howald [Island Conservation’s Global Affairs Director] first came to us 18 years ago for help with the Anacapa project we bought new equipment to make larger pellets that can survive being dropped from helicopters. Then we designed wet and dry versions, wet being a bit more stable. We used the dry form on Desecheo, Choros and Chañaral because they’re desert islands. We love doing this stuff. We win the Wisconsin Friend of the Environment Award pretty much every time we enter, and we’re a pesticide company!”

Recovery of Chañaral is just beginning, but already the island is adorned with spectacular regrowth of native cacti, herbs and shrubs, including threatened species. “The vegetation is healthy and vigorous,” says Hagen. “Remarkable foliage, big juicy leaves that you never saw before. Flowers all over the place.”

The recovery of Choros and Chañaral is far from the end of the partners’ work, not even the beginning of the end, but as Churchill said of another kind of war, “perhaps the end of the beginning.” Chile has 5,000 islands, many of which desperately require ecological restoration.

Sara de Rodt on Isla Chañaral. Photo © Maria Jose Vilches/Island Conservation

Island hopping will now progress to Chile’s Juan Fernández Archipelago. First stop: 11,614-acre Robinson Crusoe Island where castaway Alexander Selkirk, inspiration for Daniel Defoe’s novel, waited four years to be rescued. Hagen was already on site when I interviewed her by phone. The challenges here dwarf the daunting ones overcome on Choros and Chañaral. The island, more than five times the size of the entire Humboldt Penguin National Reserve and with a human population of about 1,000, is an alien hell of bramble, rabbits, coatis, house mice, black rats, Norway rats, cattle, horses and feral goats and cats.

Juan Fernández firecrown male. Photo © Island Conservation

One of the more stunning Robinson Crusoe natives is the critically endangered Juan Fernández firecrown, the world’s only oceanic hummingbird and found nowhere else. To conserve energy in its cold, montane forest it uses its large feet to hang from flowers instead of hovering like other hummingbirds, making it vulnerable to mammalian predators it didn’t evolve with. So extreme is the sexual dimorphism that early naturalists thought the male (fiery rufous-orange with an iridescent reddish-yellow crown) and the female (metallic green with a white belly and bluish-green crown) were different species.

“I get mushy when I talk about these birds because I did my graduate work on them,” says Hagen. “They’re really important pollinators. They capture the hearts of everyone who sees them. They have an amazing, trilling vocalization, and they’re so curious they come right up to people. They visit gardens where locals have planted native flowers. It’s important for people to see firecrowns, but because of all the cats it’s very dangerous for them to come down into town. Unfortunately, they don’t have a choice because invasives have so impoverished their native forest.”

Despite all the work ahead, the partners are upbeat. “What we’re really excited about,” says Hagen, “is that with all the support generated by our successes on Choros and Chañaral we can now leverage more island recovery in Chile.”

Juan Fernández firecrown female. Photo © Island Conservation

Lea una traducción al español de este artículo sobre Island Conservation.

Ted Williams

Ted Williams detests baseball, but is as obsessed with fishing as was the “real” (or, as he much prefers, “late”) Ted Williams. What he finds really discouraging is when readers meet him in person and still think he’s the frozen ballplayer. The surviving Ted writes full time on fish and wildlife issues. In addition to freelancing for national publications, he serves as national chair of the Native Fish Coalition. More from Ted

Join the Discussion

Please note that all comments are moderated and may take some time to appear.

48 comments

  1. As is all too depressingly familiar, man’s attempt to “solve” a perceived ecological or environmental problem, only results in creating a larger and often disastrous problem. Many thanks to Ted and the dedicated wildlife professionals for trying to undo the damage__to speak and act for those creatures without a voice.

    1. Hi Joel, I agree – we’ve made a mess of the world. We’re grateful that we can take action on islands and reverse the damage. Many thanks for your support! Best, Sally

  2. This story is so wonderful. And those first paired photos are especially glorious. Thank you to Ted Williams, Bell Laboratories, Island Conservation, the Chilean National Forest Corporation, and all the other people who have made this success possible. May it be followed by much more success on other islands.

    I especially needed to read this today after being reminded that in the U.S., especially in urban areas, wildlife management decisions are too often driven by the loudest and most ecologically-illiterate locals. Southeastern Michigan and especially Ann Arbor, I’m looking at you and your lunatic deer policies. It’s a wonder you have any wildflowers and butterflies left at all. I’m so grateful that Chileans are making smarter, saner decisions and are reaping the rewards they deserve.

    1. On behalf of everyone at Island Conservation, thank you Anne for your support! Best, Sally

    1. On behalf of Island Conservation, thank you Tom! Best, Sally

  3. Ted,
    Congrats on your un-thawing! Fantastic, uplifting article! It made my day!
    Best,
    Mike

  4. I’m just so amazed at the recovery of the vegetation on these islands, I’m just curious if any of it had to be reintroduced or did it all come back naturally?

    1. Hi Neal! I work for Island Conservation. The vegetation came back completely on it’s own. Most island plants and animals recover on their own. In the Galapagos, we’ve had lizard species that we thought were extinct literally crawl out from under rocks. Pretty remarkable to see! Thanks, Sally

  5. Is it just me, or is this article r e a l l y biased in favor of spreading poison to kill the rabbits?

    1. I thought so, too. It seemed very defensive. I would have liked to know more about the return of the island to its native state, rather than read a fairly scathing discourse on how soft-hearted critics (and I include myself in that group) oppose the poisoning of animals. It’s a terrible way for any creature to die. I wish I had a better suggestion to solve problems like this.

  6. Great article.
    Kudos to the various agencies involved in this work. Island restoration provides best opportunity for species recovery (and just makes so much sense).

    Opportunities exist in Australia on a few rabbit-invaded islands. The tools exist…. but does the agency interest?

  7. Hi Jared: For an article to be “biased” there has to be another side — i.e. a somewhat reasonable alternative. When it comes to saving native ecosystems by eliminating an invasive alien there is not.

  8. Ted, once again you’ve proven yourself as the best damn wildlife journalist in North America. Thanks for continuing to fight the good fight and your work to educate the lay public on the complexities of real world conservation efforts.

  9. Great to see my hero, Finn, again. Better to spend time with him in person on Robinson Crusoe Island but wonderful to hear his story and enormous contribution to such a vital mission described in a very well written article.

    Thank you, Ted! Any chance of getting a Spanish translation for distribution to all our friends in Chile?

  10. Hi again Ken:
    This just in from our mutual pal Sally:
    Thanks for sending over! Yes we can get your piece translated and sent to Ken to distribute to his network. I’m actually going to see Ken today, so I will let him know. We’ll post on our Spanish site as well. I am hearing great feedback on your article! My deepest thanks to you for covering this!

    1. Hi Ted, Please let me know once you have a link to the translation from Sally. We would love to link to it at the end of the Cool Green Science post. Thank you!

      1. Hi Lisa! Yes! Will send it to you as soon as we have it – should be ready by tomorrow. Thanks! Sally

  11. The removal/restoration/recovery program described in this article exemplifies what I admire about the Nature Conservancy efforts — science-based, sane, able to be tough and caring at the same time. It very much touches directly on why I support the Nature Conservancy.

  12. Well done article -refreshing to read a positive story about the environment

  13. Why can’t you work your magic on the rats of the NYC subway system (the rodents, not the people)?

  14. Now I know why they served delicious picked rabbit as a starter at The Singular Hotel in Puerto Natalas, Chile. Seriously, this is a great story. Quite an amazing transformation to the islands.

  15. Thank you for your heart-warming story of the transformation of Choros and Chanaral islands. I too would have objected to using a pesticide, but I see now the big upside and the small downside of that action. And incidentally, I have fallen in love with the Juan Fernandez Firecrown hummingbirds. How extraordinarily beautiful they are!!

  16. HOW LONG DID IT TAKE FOR THE RABBITS AND FOXES TO DIE ONCE EATING THE POSION???

    WHAT DID YOU DO WITH ALL THE DEAD BODIES??

    YOU NEED TO SHOW THE VIDEOS/PICTURES OF THE DESTRUCTION…………

    SORRY, NOT INTO
    CAUSING PAIN AND SUFFERING FOR ANY LIVE CREATURE………….

    I THINK THE PUBLIC SHOULD OF BEEN CONSULTED BEFORE YOU DECIDED ON “POISON”……AND

    DONE HUMANE TRAPS AND HUMANE EUTHANIZING ………….

    YOU CAN’T HAVE COMPASSION FOR ONE SPECIES AND NOT ALL……….THAT IS NOT BEING A “HUMAN BEING”

    SHAME ON ALL OF YOU.

    1. Nice use of all caps, senior citizen. If you read the article, it would be more inhumane not to protect the natives from the invasives. Live trapping, seriously? Do you know how impossible that would be? Are you familiar with how fast rabbits breed? Kudos to the Nature Conservancy for choosing the best solution at hand and executing it.

      1. Is that your idea of an insult ,”senior citizen” ? Very adult discourse.

      2. Are u familiar w/ how fast other species besides rabbits breed & wouldn’t it be wonderful if the same genius we apply to other innocent species (introduced where they shouldn’t have been thru no power of their own) could be found to remedy scenarios e.g. the destruction of the world’s deepest fresh water lake Baikal in Russia from sewage & chemical pollution? And striking how these photos compare to before & after photos of forever lost beauty Canada’s coniferous forests after tar sands destruction & before & after photos of clear cut old growth forests in the U.S. & So. American jungles or before & after photos denuded hillside mudslides or photos of desertification in Africa & other areas. Amazing how ‘we’ can deal so ‘efficiently’ w/ ‘other species’ to save the world, isn’t it?
        “…what critics have right is that non target bykill is nearly inevitable…but what the critics don’t comprehend is that, in ecological and species-level contexts, this bykill has zero significance.” At least that’s how easy it is to view all ‘other’ species we share this earth with. “But It Is Not In Nature’s Plan, All Else Should Die But Egoman.”

    2. Linda,
      I agree with you 100%. In my humble opinion, Mankind is the true invasive species.

  17. The addition of Finn, looking much like my Yellow Lab, made the story even more wonderful. Thank you!

  18. To reclaim what was lost due to lack of forethought is amazing. Wonderful work. Many thanks.

  19. I sadly applaud the partnership of the (responsible!) pesticide and conservation folks. The introduction of ferral domestic european animals into wildlands has had horrible consequences. Bunnies are designed to be a rapidly reproduced and preyed-upon species–mother nature’s fast food. I am a card carrying member of the American House Rabbit Society and have two pet spayed rescued bunnies loose with hay/litter boxes in my apartment. I love them dearly but i know the piles of hay and greens they devour and you needn’t remind me of how efficiently they chew. The introduced virus myxomiotosis works cruelly and lengthely, besides in the end being useless to eradicating wild populations and posing a continuing viral threat to pets. These projects were well thought out, well targeted, and resulted in success.

  20. very impressive. I had no idea; saw evidence of widespread poisoning in New Zealand on a tour, but no real follow-up information
    david smith

  21. Love the success but do wonder where it is healthy for rabbits, I guess where they have natural predators, love their furry selves too

  22. I’m still not on board with pesticides or murder of the innocent not asking to be put there. I see the beauty on that island, yes; I understand that a group of very ignorant people caused the demise of these innocent rabbits, yes; I cannot support pesticide use because of their stupidity, no; and I believe there was a better way to solve these problems. I am sorry for my non supportive opinion. I’m not certain I can donate to your organization any longer:(

  23. It might be a good idea to poison the rabbits and rats on Robinson Crusoe Island, but if they want to rid the island of the cattle, horses, goats and cats, a humane way of transporting them elsewhere should be found.

  24. Only wish I was wealthy and able to fund more of what you’re doing with those islands. Godspeed.

  25. Thank you for the frankness of the article. We often read about successes without knowing the facts . I’m heartened to know that a company that deals in pesticides have a positive side instead of viewing them as irresponsible and anti-environment. My eyes are constantly opened to the depth and breath of the work you do and thank God for organizations like yours.

  26. Fascinating and encouraging article on eradicating exotic mammals. Jumping to another island, Maui, any similar progress in eliminating feral hogs?

  27. The results of this program appear to be amazing. Congratulations on using science instead of guesswork in developing a plan. I am curious, however-is Island Conservancy planning to target all of the invasive species on Robinson Crusoe Island, or focus on some of the most harmful? What of species such as cows and horses that are beneficial to the island’s inhabitants? Will the inhabitants be compensated for the loss of productive animals? Do the inhabitants buy in to the eradication plan, or is it imposed with or without their agreement?