A boat glides down a river in the Amazon region. Photo: © borderlys/Flickr

Por Favor, Brasil: Keep Debating, and You Can Change the World

by Michael A. Reuter, The Nature Conservancy’s director of freshwater for North America. Follow him on Twitter @michaelareuter

Food. Water. Energy. All this situated within some of the most beautiful, productive and diverse ecosystems on the planet. Few places have what Brazil has.

It’s an abundance that comes with great responsibility. Because from here on billions of people globally—perhaps nine billion by 2050—will look to Brazil, whether they know it or not, for essential goods and services. Management of the country’s water resources will truly impact us all, a nós todos!

Talk about pressure.

So what does “getting it right” look like?

That’s something a lot of Brazilians are debating these days. Indeed, a sense of frustration streamed through the Brazilian Water Resources Forum in Bento Gonzales this past November.

More than a thousand leading water professionals gathered there to share ideas and, at times, challenge each other’s thinking about how to best work through impasses to smart development and balance demands on the nation’s substantial water resources.

A particularly lively session focused on the Tapajós River—a tributary of the Amazon about the size of the Ohio River. While rich with resources and opportunity, the Tapajós faces competing needs and conflicting visions about energy, transportation, mining, conservation and more.

One participant compared its Amazon River Basin to a dog that starves because it has too many owners. Another likened management of the great waterway to owning a powerful computer that has no software—abundant in resources, but unable to make a decision!

Moving in the Right Direction

Spotted Treefrog (Hypsiboas punctatus) in Oiapoque, in the northern Brazilian Amazon, one of the mosaics where our Amazon indigenous strategy works. We have been partnering with local indigenous communities in Oiapoque since 2001 to demonstrate how indige

Realizing balance and progress at this scale is hard. It’s so hard that it’s near impossible to find decent examples from elsewhere around the world.

It requires putting roads, ports and waterways, hydropower dams, railroads and other infrastructure in the right places, with the right technology. These places need to be prepared to absorb the negative impacts of development that come along with the many benefits for nature and people.

For example, railroads, ports and waterways encourage agricultural development in some areas over others by providing substantial economic efficiencies. But they also drive consequences, such as sacrificing Brazil’s unique rainforests and savannas and other ecological systems that sustain us with clean water and fisheries. Shortsighted or poorly planned development may even undermine itself as these agricultural supply chains are boycotted in international markets.

Many organizations in Brazil, including The Nature Conservancy, are focused on “getting it right” in the Tapajós River Basin. The Tapajós flows north through the fast-developing agricultural region of Mato Grosso and Pará, and then winds through some of the most pristine rainforests before joining the Amazon at Santarém.

Protests levied against the first port facility at Santarém led the Conservancy to the Tapajós a decade ago to forge a partnership with Cargill in an effort to ensure that all soybeans purchased met rigorous standards for sustainability. This partnership influenced the new Brazilian Forest Code, an attempt to reconcile agriculture and conservation.

It also spurred creation of a new land use management mechanism named Cadastro Ambiental Rural (Rural Environmental Registry), which allows Brazil to manage how private landowners use and maintain forests. 

Now the Tapajós River faces a massive expansion of the land and water transportation network that will be needed to move all this grain across the world. At the same time, it is targeted for large-scale hydropower development as part of Brazil’s overall energy plans (85 percent of the country’s energy comes from hydropower).

Brazilians at the Wheel

Conservancy-sponsored meeting with farmers and ranchers in São Félix do Xingu, in the state of Pará, Brazil. Understanding that conversion to agriculture and cattle ranching is the greatest threat to the Amazon rainforest, the Conservancy works in stra

So who has the know-how to integrate all these needs and make the wise decisions that will change the world? 

Brazilians, of course!

Not one or two, but many of them working together—each bringing their personal values and perspectives into a joint decision-making process that is supported by goodwill and biased toward action. National-level decision makers will need to break out of their sector silos, and work to support integrated decisions on energy, transportation, conservation, and more. There is also a need for crossing these borders into a watershed-based approach. 

Of course, without goodwill or trust such diverse perspectives can be disabling. Many of us in the U.S. have had a good dose of that lately. Given the complexity and scientific uncertainty that abound in great rivers like the Tapajós, stakeholders won’t even be able to agree on the questions to ask, much less use the same science or settle on the same answers, if they don’t develop mutual respect and trust.

But with trust present, a collective voice can make more progress possible. By staying in the game, Brazilians have every potential to realize the incredible creativity and innovation that flows from having diverse perspectives present when solving grand dilemmas. And they can look to others for help, because we all need Brazil.

So what’s really possible when we focus on shared solutions and shared value?

Well, for one, hydropower development can be much more compatible with other river resources. This has been illustrated by efforts such as the re-engineering of Penobscot River in Maine. There they’ve realized dramatic increases in habitat for salmon and other migratory fish while maintaining or increasing energy generation. The key is to move hydropower planning and operation away from a focus on single dams and toward a whole river basin or region.

Brazilians can do this. And if they embrace all stakeholders in the process, they will likely get smarter and more lasting solutions. So, por favor, Brasil, stay in the game. Keep debating, and you might just change the world.

[Images: Boat in Amazon River Basin – © borderlys/Flickr; spotted tree frog in Amazon region – © Fábio Maffei; meeting of Brazilian farmers and ranchers – © Leandro Ramos] 

Opinions expressed on Conservancy Talk and in any corresponding comments are the personal opinions of the original authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Conservancy.

If you believe in the work we’re doing, please lend a hand.

Add a Comment